Design a distillation column for separating a binary mixture of Components A and
B
.
The feed mixture consists of
4
0
%
A and
6
0
%
B
.
The objective is to determine the optimum reflux ratio th

Question

Design a distillation column for separating a binary mixture of Components A and 
B
.
 ﻿The feed mixture consists of 
4
0
%
A and 
6
0
%
B
.
 ﻿The objective is to determine the optimum reflux ratio that minimizes the total annual cost of the distillation column. Given data :
Feed flow rate : 
1
0
0
0
k
g
h
,
 ﻿Feed composition : 
4
0
%
A
,
 
6
0
%
B
,
 ﻿distillate flow rate : 
8
0
0
k
g
h
,
 ﻿Bottoms flow rate : 
2
0
0
k
g
h
,
 ﻿Feed temperature : 
8
0
°
C
,
 ﻿Boiling point of 
A
:
7
0
°
C
,
 ﻿Boiling point of B: 
9
0
°
C
,
 ﻿Heat duty : 
5
0
,
0
0
0
 ﻿kealh, Annual operating hours : 
8
7
6
0
 ﻿hours, Annual interest rate : 
1
0
%
,
 ﻿Plant lifetime : 
1
0
 ﻿years, Salvage value : 
1
0
%
 ﻿of the initial investment, Cost of utilities ; $
0
.
1
0
 ﻿per kWh 
,
 ﻿Cost of raw materials : $
2
 ﻿per kg 
.

VIPSolutions · Accepted Answer

Let's break down the **distillation column design** and **economic optimization** for the separation of a binary mixture (A and B) as requested.

---

## **1. Data Summary**

- **Feed flow rate ($ F $)**: 1000 kg/h
- **Feed composition**: $ x_{F,A} = 0.40 $, $ x_{F,B} = 0.60 $
- **Distillate flow ($ D $)**: 800 kg/h
- **Bottoms flow ($ B $)**: 200 kg/h
- **Feed temperature**: 80°C
- **Boiling points**: A = 70°C, B = 90°C
- **Heat duty ($ Q $)**: 50,000 kcal/h
- **Annual operating hours**: 8,760 h
- **Interest rate**: 10%
- **Plant lifetime**: 10 years
- **Salvage value**: 10% of initial investment
- **Utility cost**: $0.10 per kWh
- **Raw material cost**: $2 per kg

---

## **2. Mass Balance Check**

- **Input**: 1000 kg/h
- **Output**: 800 kg/h (distillate) + 200 kg/h (bottoms) = 1000 kg/h ✔

---

## **3. Material Balance on Components**

Let’s denote:
- $ x_D $ = mass fraction of A in distillate
- $ x_B $ = mass fraction of A in bottoms

**Total A in feed:**
$$
A_{in} = 1000 \times 0.40 = 400 \text{ kg/h}
$$

**A in distillate + bottom:**
$$
A_{out} = 800 x_D + 200 x_B
$$
$$
800 x_D + 200 x_B = 400
$$
You need to specify the desired purity for A in distillate and B in bottoms. For illustration, let's assume:
- Distillate: $ x_D = 0.48 $ (i.e., 48% A)
- Bottoms: $ x_B = 0.02 $ (i.e., 2% A)

Check:
$$
800 \times 0.48 + 200 \times 0.02 = 384 + 4 = 388 \text{ kg/h}
$$
This does not exactly sum to 400 kg/h, so the purities may need to be adjusted. For further calculation, use above as a working example.

---

## **4. Energy Cost Calculation**

**Heat duty ($ Q $):** 50,000 kcal/h

Convert to kWh:
$$
1 \text{ kWh } = 860 \text{ kcal}
$$
$$
Q = \frac{50,000}{860} = 58.14 \text{ kWh/h}
$$

**Annual energy consumption:**
$$
E_{annual} = 58.14 \times 8,760 = 509,346 \text{ kWh/year}
$$

**Annual energy cost:**
$$
C_{energy} = 509,346 \times 0.10 = \$50,935
$$

---

## **5. Raw Materials Cost**

$$
\text{Annual feed: } 1000 \text{ kg/h} \times 8,760 = 8,760,000 \text{ kg/year}
$$
$$
C_{raw} = 8,760,000 \times 2 = \$17,520,000
$$

---

## **6. Capital Cost (Estimation)**

Let's assume the capital cost ($ C_{cap} $) is a function of the number of trays, column diameter, and materials. A typical shortcut is:

$$
C_{cap} = a + b \cdot N
$$
Where $ N $ is number of trays (function of reflux ratio), and $ a, b $ are constants.

**Annualized capital cost:**
$$
\text{Annualized Cost} = \frac{C_{cap} \times i (1 + i)^n}{(1 + i)^n - 1} - S
$$
Where:
- $ i = 0.1 $ (interest rate)
- $ n = 10 $ years
- $ S = $ salvage value (10% of $ C_{cap} $), spread over years

But for optimization, what matters is how $ C_{cap} $ changes with **number of stages** and **reflux ratio**.

---

## **7. Reflux Ratio and Optimization**

### **Trade-off:**

- **Higher reflux ratio** ($ R $): Lower number of stages, higher energy cost.
- **Lower reflux ratio**: Higher number of stages (capital cost), lower energy cost.

### **Minimum Reflux Ratio ($ R_{min} $)**

Estimate using the McCabe-Thiele method (requires equilibrium data—let’s outline steps):

- **At $ R_{min} $:** The operating line touches the equilibrium curve. Number of stages is infinite, energy cost is minimum.
- **At total reflux:** Minimum stages, maximum energy cost.

### **Optimum Reflux Ratio ($ R_{opt} $)**

**Empirical rule:** Optimum reflux ratio is 1.2 to 1.5 times $ R_{min} $.

$$
R_{opt} = 1.2 \sim 1.5 \times R_{min}
$$

### **Procedure:**

1. **Estimate $ R_{min} $** (needs more data; for now, **assume $ R_{min} = 1.5 $**).
2. **Calculate number of stages at $ R_{opt} $** using empirical correlations or McCabe-Thiele (assume for illustration: at $ R_{opt} = 2 $, stages needed = 15).
3. **Estimate capital cost as function of stages.**
4. **Calculate total annual cost (TAC):**
    $$
    \text{TAC} = \text{Annualized Capital Cost} + \text{Annual Energy Cost}
    $$
5. **Vary $ R $, find minimum TAC.**

---

## **8. Example Calculation**

Assume:

- $ R_{min} = 1.5 $
- $ R_{opt} = 2.0 $
- Number of stages ($ N_{opt} $) = 15

**Capital cost model:**
$$
C_{cap} = \$20,000 + \$5,000 \times N
$$
So,
$$
C_{cap, opt} = 20,000 + 5,000 \times 15 = \$95,000
$$

**Annualized capital cost (10% interest, 10 years):**
$$
\text{Annualized cost} = \frac{95,000 \times 0.1 \times (1.1)^{10}}{(1.1)^{10} - 1}
$$
$$
(1.1)^{10} = 2.5937
$$
$$
= \frac{95,000 \times 0.1 \times 2.5937}{2.5937 - 1} = \frac{24,640}{1.5937} = \$15,463 \text{ per year}
$$

**Energy cost:** As above, \$50,935 per year.

**Total annual cost:**
$$
TAC = 15,463 + 50,935 = \$66,398
$$

Repeat for other reflux ratios (e.g., $ R = 1.5 $, $ N = 22 $), plot $ TAC $ vs $ R $, find minimum.

---

## **9. Conclusion & Recommendation**

**Optimum reflux ratio ($ R_{opt} $)** is typically **1.2–1.5 times the minimum reflux ratio**. For this example, assuming $ R_{min} = 1.5 $, $ R_{opt} \approx 2.0 $.

- **At $ R_{opt} = 2.0 $, number of stages = 15**
- **

✨ VIPSolutions

Question:

Final Answer:

📢 Instructions:

Study Help, Fast Answers

✨ VIPSolutions

Question:

Final Answer:

📢 Instructions:

Related Answers

Study Help, Fast Answers